From the archive

Try this: The Rice Pudding Martini

By eatdrinknjJersey City

At Michael Anthony's

A creamy martini dusted with cinnamon on a dark bar
Generated editorial illustration

When I was a kid, my favorite cereal was Cinnamon Toast Crunch. The sweet little toast flakes made getting to the school bus a little more bearable, and the milk at the bottom of the bowl would always taste like cinnamon.

Even though it’s way too sugary for my palate these days, I still enjoy a bowl once in awhile. We’ll call it a guilty pleasure.

So imagine my delight when I had a rice pudding martini at Michael Anthony’s on Monday and the taste immediately conjured up images of that cartoony chef on the box that so often adorned my pantry shelf.

It’s a creamy drink comprised of rum chata and malibu and topped with cinnamon, this drink recreates the magic of the cinnamon-infused milk that would await me at the end of breakfast.

Granted, it’s not quite as sweet, but the fact that it’s a martini more than makes up for it. Thank god I didn’t have access to these as a kid.

What: The Rice Pudding Martini

Where: Michael Anthony’s 

Cost: $13

Want a discount? Grab our VIP card!

Plan a day in Jersey City

Two Jersey City holiday markets to put on the calendar

The Heights Holiday Market and the downtown Happy Holiday Market both open December 5. Here’s where to go and when.

Explore by town

iOS launch alert

We’ll email you when the app is available. Privacy

Android launch alert

We’ll email you when the app is available. Privacy