From the archive

Hats off to HAT Tavern, a true Summit treasure

By eatdrinknj

At Hat Tavern

Seared meat and roasted root vegetables on an off-white tavern plate
Generated editorial illustration

Tucked away in the Grand Summit Hotel, HAT Tavern is anything but a well-kept secret. It’s success since opening early in 2011 has reignited the legacy behind its name and delighted thousands with its outstanding farm to table cooking and staggering beer menu.

“Can’t get enough of the HAT Tavern? Get all the info and discounts on their venue page!“

The tavern is the creation of South Florida celebrity chef Tony Sindaco, who most likely left for the state of New Jersey after dealing with the joy of Florida drivers for a couple years. Whether or not the game of geriatric bumper cars influenced his move, he left behind the wildly successful Sunfish Grill in Fort Lauderdale for his next venture.

Although the name is a play off of former owner Harry A. Taylor’s initials, the tavern now sports a classy looking derby hat in the logo, and the kitchen has one classy goal: serve the best burger around.

Eats

So let’s talk about the food. The HAT Tavern uses Pat LaFrieda beef, which is a Manhattan based purveyor that only does business with great restaurants, hotels, and banquet halls. The meat is naturally raised and hormone free, graded USDA Choice Prime. That means your burger is now a specialty burger.

On top of that, a large selection of tapas and salads and “Jersey Fresh” locally grown foods make up the brunt of the menu. Let’s have a look at the things we samples.

First we snagged a taste of the pan-fried lump crab vermicelli cake, served with a side of tomato relish and roasted garlic aioli. Besides looking pretty (see below), it tastes superb as well. Now, those of you that known me have a good idea of my stance on crab cakes. Done well, they’re the best thing ever. Cut some corners, however, and you have a lump of inedible detritus that you’ll be asking your waiter to do away with pronto. Not the case here. Fresh, flavorful, and surprisingly light, this one was a winner.

I also tried my other favorite seafood item, the scallops, which frequently show up on locally sourced menus thanks to our close approximation to the ocean. These were a bit differet, though. The most common way to get your scallops is pan seared, but these are fried and served with pesto mayo. I was a little cautious at first, I’ll admit, but they melted in my mouth with the pesto mayo complimenting it fearlessly. Bravo.

Then I dug into two burgers, the Jim Cramer’s Mad Money Burger and the Greek Lamb Burger. While the former will not help you invest your stocks more wisely, it’s a good test of the LaFrieda brand and bursts with a range of flavor not usually tasted in your run of the mill ground beef. The lamb on the otherhand was well prepared and appropriately pink where it needed to be. It was also very moist, which is good considering that lamb can dry out if you’re not careful. Add in tzatziki sauce and you’ve got a kind of a gyro. It’s quite good.

I wanted more, but I was full. The only things left to nosh on were the boardwalk style fries, which my coworker claims are the best she’s ever tasted. It’s a bold claim. I wouldn’t agree without serious contemplation and comparison. But it’s up there.

You can check the rest of the menu out here, and don’t forget to red up on their impressive brunch menu as well.

Drinks

Probably the most talked about aspect of the HAT Tavern is the beer selection, which frequently cycles through more than ten microbrews and frequently has them on draft. The best part is that they’re filling growlers now, so watch out for that. You can see the full drink menu here.

I did have an Allagash White, simply because it’s one of my top beers, but I wanted to save room for some of the signatures. Unfortunately I only had time for one, which was the Pumpkin Shy martini, which is a new seasonal comprised of Voyant Chai cream liqueur, Stoli Vanilla, and fresh ground cinnamon. Not too shabby, and it certainly made me yearn for Autumn to hurry the heck up already.

One more thing worth mentioning are the milkshakes, which are decadent, and the Boylan Root Beer, which is a soda that New Jerseyans know all too well. If you don’t want to drink or you’re the designated driver (shoulda called Stear Clear!), you won’t be left out in the proverbial cold.

I also wanted to mention the Scotch list, which has an impressive amount of Islay Scotch from LaPhroiag to Lagavulin.

Specials

A restaurant like HAT Tavern doesn’t really need specials since they already have a lot going on to entice people through their doors, but they went the extra mile anyway. Their happy hour from 4-7pm features $2 off draft beer and $3 off well drinks, which is quite good, and they have daily specials as well:

Manic Monday
SIN (Service Industry Night) 9:00 pm – Close
1/2 Price Tapas/ $2 Domestic Drafts/$3 Domestic Bottles

Tippy Tuesday
9:00 pm – Close
$5 Cosmo’s & Margarita’s

Wine Wednesday
7:00 pm – Close
25% OFF any bottle of wine with dinner/$10 Carafes of Sangria

Thirsty Thursday
9:00 pm – Close
BYOC (Bring Your Own Cup) $5 Coors Light Draft
$5 Personal Cheese Pizza’s till 11 pm

Sports Sunday
7:00 pm – Close
$2 OFF All Draft Beers

Deals

Why yes, I’ve got two deals for you. All you have to do is print them out and bring them in to your waiter. The first gets you 50% off a bottle of wine when you purchase two entrees. The second is a football deal that gets you Buffalo Wings, Crispy Fried Calamari, Beer Battered Mozzarella Sticks and 2 Craft Draft Beers all for only $29.99. Boom!  Click here to get it!

Events

The HAT has a lot going on for a place that isn’t a sports bar. You can always see their event schedule right here on their website, or see what’s coming soon on our events page.

September is looking to be a fun month. Here’s what they have coming up:

September 19th

Spagetti & Sinatra
6-9 pm

September 20th

Guys Night Out!
NY Giants @Carolina- 8:20 Kick-off
Food & drink specials all night!!

September 26th
New Jersey BeerTap Take-Over!
6-9 pm
Acoustic Music w/Michael Andrew
Open to Public

September 29th

Nashville Recording Artist Nikki Brier

& the Sweetbriar Band Performs!
9-12 PM

In conclusion

There’s a lot to love about HAT Tavern, from its food and service to the Elizabethan gardens that liven up the patio in the back. They hit all the right notes: Local food, local brews, growlers, world class menu items, and there’s still much for us to explore. Stick around and check back for when we do. We predict good things.

Gallery

Story photos

  • Hat Tavern (23 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (24 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (22 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (7 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (25 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (21 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (19 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (17 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (11 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (4 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (16 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (13 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (14 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (18 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (3 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (2 of 25)
  • Hat Tavern (13 of 25)

Plan your next stop

A Hoboken waterfront walk with two happy hour stops

Start at Pier A, head up the Hudson, then choose between dollar oysters and Italian aperitivo on Washington Street.

Explore by town

iOS launch alert

We’ll email you when the app is available. Privacy

Android launch alert

We’ll email you when the app is available. Privacy