From the archive
Eating NJ’s hottest chicken wing: a tale of bad decisions

I’ve been known to make bad decisions when I’m feeling indecisive. It’s one of my many flaws (or charms, as I call them!). Coincidentally, my friend and roommate Ashley is the same way. And when both of us are feeling indecisive, it’s simply guaranteed that neither of us are going to get what we want. This week was a painful reminder of that.
The George Street Ale House is awesome. Click here for discounts, drink specials, and more!
It all started when I saw a Facebook invite on Wednesday morning: “Anthony Xerri LIVE at the George Street Ale House!”
Maybe I’ll go, I thought, not expecting my day to be very strenuous. I love the Ale House, and Anthony is a good friend of mine. But after a long and tedious day of eating and drinking, the only thing I wanted to do as I walked into my apartment was sleep.
I should sleep, I thought. I’ll just take a nap.
But I’d no sooner hit the sheets when my phone suddenly had a seizure and rattled itself off the desk to an onslaught of notifications. Groaning, I bent down and picked it up. Hey, a text from Anthony!
“Coming out tonight buddy?”
I looked back and forth between my phone and my bed like a scene from a cartoon. I was so tired, but it was only 10pm. And that made me feel old. Now I had to go out just to prove to myself that I can still hang with the other 25 year olds. I’ll show those whippersnappers, I thought.
Be right there, I responded. I stuck my head into Ashley’s room to see if she wanted to go. “Heck yes!” she said, as usual, and we headed into town to watch our friend’s acoustic set. It would be a good time, and besides, I hadn’t seen the guy in a few weeks. Within ten minutes, I parked and we were sitting at a table.
Feedback buzzed from the speakers as Anthony set up, and then our stomachs groaned in an eerily similar fashion: It was time for food, and we both knew it. But what to eat? Everything sounded so good.
Her: What are you getting?
Me: I don’t know, you?
Her: I don’t know.
Me: Want to split something?
Her: Sure!
Me: What should we get?
Her: I don’t know, what do you want?
Me: I don’t know.
Uh oh. The conversation went downhill from there, as it always does when we can’t decide on something. It escalated from there, and eventually things got heated.
Her: Why don’t you just have the poo-brain salad?!
Me: That’s not even a thing!
Her: Like you would know!
Me: I would know, I know everything!
Her: Except what you want to eat!
Me, mockingly: Except what you want to eat!
Her: Fine, then, let’s get wings!
Me: Fine! See if I care!
Her: I don’t care if you care!
Me: Good! What flavor do you want?
Her: I don’t know, which flavor do you want?
A few minutes of arguing later, the sounds of Anthony starting his set filled the room and the music made bickering seem pointless. We both looked at the flavors and actually read them. Mild, Medium, Hot, BBQ, Teriyaki…. ghost chili? What the heck was that? It seemed familiar to me, but all I could think of was a haunted bowl of Hormel. I decided to look it up on my phone.
According to Wikipedia, the Ghost Chili, or Naga Bhut Jolokia, is one of the hottest peppers in the world. In fact, it held the Guinness world record for spiciness until the Trinidad Moruga Scorpian pepper was deemed hotter a couple years later.
Now, to give you an idea, the “heat” in peppers is measured in units called Scoville Heat Units. A jalapeño pepper is rated between 3,500–8,000 Scoville units, while cayenne pepper sits between 30,000–50,000 Scovilles. Conversely, a habañero pepper can reach levels of up to 350,000 Scoville units, and that is nothing to joke with. One drop of that in your eye and you’ll be in the hospital.
How about the ghost chili pepper? Well, it rates between 855,000–1,463,700 Scoville units. So yes, it’s very hot. And Ashley decided we should try it.
I’ll level with you, folks. I’m a big baby when it comes to hot stuff. Mild, if not BBQ, is the way to go when ordering wings. Enjoy the taste, I say. But here I was, being challenged at the height of yet another pointless argument, and I wasn’t going to back down.
“Let’s do it.”
I should have known it was a terrible decision when, after ordering, the manager, Wes, walked over to our table and reasoned that we should order something less spicy. On account of it making people want to drown themselves in a swimming pool of milk.
We wanted to try it still, and he acquiesced. But instead of ordering a full plate, which he felt we realistically would not finish, we ordered some teriyaki wings with a single ghost chili wing on the side.
“There are some ground rules,” he continued, as the sinking feeling in my stomach worsened.
“You will sweat, cry and your nose will release all of its mucus,” he said. ”Keep your hands as far away from your face and genitals as possible.”
I laughed. Ash hit me. It was time. The wings came out. A little neat pile of teriyaki wings waited to be enjoyed while a single surprisingly bright-orange wing sat sequestered on the other end of the plate. Was he protecting the other wings from its hellish heat as well?
I started eating teriyaki wings. I wanted to enjoy them since I didn’t think eating would really appeal to me for a couple days after trying the ghost chili. Just as I started eating a delicious little drumstick, however, Ashley grabbed the ghost chili wing and took a bite.
“You’re supposed to wait!” I cried, shooting a pleading look at the teriyaki wings.
“I’m impatient,” she replied, chewing . “It’s surprisingly sweet. It’s really not that–”
She froze.
“What? It’s really not that what?”
Her breathing quickened. Her face turned red. Sweat started to pour down her face. It was building. She reached for her beer and took a huge swig.
“Oh god oh god oh god!”
Is it bad?” I asked.
She nodded rapidly.
“It’s getting worse!”
I watched in slight amusement as she chugged her entire beer and went diving into the ramekin of ranch to try to cool the burn. Now it was my turn. I was determined to act tough even though I was fairly sure I was going to die and said goodbye to the world under my breath.
I took a small nip, slightly smaller than Ashley’s bite. She was right, it was sweet. Actually, it was very tasty, and there was no initial burn. But suddenly, it was like someone lit a match in my mouth. Every little spot that the wing touched started burning wildly, and became more painful by the minute.
At this point, I said a lot of curse words and chugged my cocktail.
Fat chance. The pain built solidly for five minutes, but believe me, it felt like an hour. After that, it slowly petered off as either A) my saliva’s enzymes neutralized the heat or B) my nerves were simply melted and unable to process pain. I’m still not sure which.
The heat from a ghost chili just builds and builds and builds. It doesn’t seem to stop. I noticed that everyone, Wes included, was laughing at us. Most of the staff had tried it before and would never try it again. I could see why. I started dipping the celery and carrots into ranch until there weren’t any carrots or celery left. Then I started dunking my finger into the ranch and shoveled it into my mouth to try to neutralize the burn.
At that point, Anthony started playing Magic Carpet Ride and I fell into some sort of trance. I figured I would probably wake up somewhere in the streets of New Brunswick. Was this a transition into death? No, turns out the cocktail I chugged was really damned strong. I was drunk.
And I wanted others to feel my pain.
The entire table next to me took a bite, went through the ritual of pain, and then sat around questioning their life choices as our waitress brought us some conciliatory beer. In the end, six people ate less than half of one wing. It was an experience that I’m glad I can brag about, but will I ever do it again? No way in hell.
But all in all, we had a lot of fun (especially when our lips stopped swelling) and I was all ready to leave in good spirits… until the bartender, Ryan, walked up to me.
“So, what did you think?” he ask
“It was brutal,” I admitted. “I’m not built for that.”
Ryan laughed. I raised my eyebrow.
“If you thought it was bad going down, just wait until it’s coming out.”
Kill me now.
The gallery of PAIN:
Story photos
- DSC_2904
- DSC_2842